What you need to know to choose the right sleeping bag and pad

Backpackers, car campers, and travelers all look for different features when shopping for a sleeping bag and pad. We’ll primarily focus on choosing the right sleep system for backpacking. You can’t sleep when you’re too cold, but too much insulation, and you’re stuck with a bag that weighs almost as much as your backpack. Sleeping bags will be one of the heavier items in your backpack. Spending time on choosing the right backpacking sleep system can be simple if you follow these tips.

Here are a few factors to consider:

  • Weight: The type of insulation along with the shape of your bag will have the most impact on the weight of your sleeping bag.
  • Types of Insulation: Down vs. Synthetic is the main choice here. Each has its own costs and benefits, which will be explained.
  • Temperature Rating: Choose a sleeping bag rated lower than the typical lowest temperatures that you are anticipating experiencing on your trips.
  • Sleep System: Being comfortable in your sleeping bag depends on many variables. Specifically, the R-value of your sleeping bag and pad – more on that later.
  • Features: There are dozens of potential features that a sleeping bag can come with. Consider which features will work best for you.

Understanding Sleeping Bag Temperature Ratings

To find a sleeping bag’s temperature rating, the manufacturer identifies the lowest temperature at which a bag is designed to keep the “average sleeper” comfortably warm. We suggest that you buy a sleeping bag that has a lower temperature rating than temperatures you expect to encounter. You can simply open a bag to cool down if your conditions are slightly too warm for your bag.

It is also important to learn about the specific terms attached to those ratings. While temperature rating can get complicated, below is all you need to know:

  • Lab-tested temperature ratings (as indicated by “EN” or “ISO” ratings) are useful for making an apples-to-apples comparison between sleeping bags from different brands.
  • Real-world comfort probably won’t match lab-tested temperature ratings because of all the variables that a lab can’t simulate – like differences in people’s clothing and gear (i.e. sleeping pads), differences in body types (warm and cold sleepers), changing weather conditions, differences in food people eat and more. So, when you use your sleeping bag in the outdoors, its comfort level will probably differ from its tested temperature rating.
  • Temperature ratings are estimates. A temperature rating is not a guarantee of warmth. It is a helpful suggestion that aids the customer in comparing bags from company to company.
Photo of Big Agnes Sleeping Bag and Sleeping Pad

Sleeping Bags and Pads Work Together

There a lot of variables between real-world warmth and the rating listed on your bag. For example, humidity, wind, type of shelter, ground conditions, clothing, and even person preference all play a role. To generally optimize your sleeping experience while backpacking though, you should look to create your ideal sleep system. A sleep system is made of three components: your sleeping bag, your sleeping pad, and your clothing.

For example, pairing a sleeping bag with a less-insulated pad at colder temps might limit the effectiveness of your bag. After all, a sleeping bag’s test rating is based on a person wearing long underwear and socks, who is also sleeping on a pad with an R-value of 5.5.

The table below shows the recommended sleep system combinations based on your expected nighttime low, R-Value, and sleeping bag temperature rating.

Expected Nighttime Low50 °F32 °F20 °F0 °F
Pad: R-Value RangeUnder 22 – 3.94 – 5.45.5+
Bag: Temperature Rating30 °F or lower20 °F or lower15 °F or lower0 °F or lower

If you’re a warm sleeper, use the “lower limit” for the temperature of the bag. If you’re a cold sleeper, use its comfort rating.

The Sleep System

Choosing an insulation type is another important step in selecting your ideal sleeping bag. Down and synthetic are the main options.

  • Down: Lightweight, compresses easily, excels in dry conditions.
  • Synthetic: Quick-drying, insulates when wet, non-allergenic

Down bags more often use a wide variety of baffled constructions. Synthetic insulation usually uses quilted, offset quilted, and/or shingled construction. The ultimate idea is to get an even distribution of insulation around your body, with no cold spots.

Below are some more considerations when choosing the insulation type:

Down insulation: More expensive on average than synthetic insulation. Down is sought after because it’s lighter and more compressible. In addition, down fill is more durable than a synthetic fill, which means it retains a more consistent level of warmth for longer periods of time (decades, if properly cared for). Here are a few common questions when considering down insulation:

  • Fill Power – Fill power essentially indicates the quality of down. The higher the number, the more warmth generated for its weight. The most expensive down bags, which are intended for extreme cold, have higher fill powers (around 800).
  • Water-Resistant Down Insulation – Because down loses insulating efficiency when wet, most down sleeping bags also feature a water-repelling treatment.
  • Responsible down – Down is a by-product of the meat industry, so bag makers have taken steps to ensure the humane treatment of animals which provide down. Look for RDS (Responsible Down Standard) and TDS (global Traceable Down Standard) designations.

Synthetic insulation offers solid performance at a price that is cheaper than down. It also continues to insulate when wet, which makes it the ideal insulation for damp climates. While synthetic insulation is available in a variety of brands, there is no widely adopted spec for synthetic insulation. To compare synthetics, we suggest looking at ISO/EN ratings.Down/Synthetic Blends: It is increasingly common for bags to be designed with synthetic insulation on the bottom and down on the top. If the bag is rolled, though, this design loses its advantage.

If the packed size of your sleeping bag in its stuff sack is the main concern, insulation is the #1 factor that you should look at. “Compressed Volume” is a handy spec for this.

Understanding Sleeping Bag Weight

In determining the weight of the sleeping bag, insulation and shape are the two largest factors. Advanced insulations like high-fill-power downs deliver greater warmth for less weight than less efficient fill options. You should always compare similarly-temperature-rated bags when comparing bag weights because a sleeping bag will require more insulation to get to a lower temperature rating.

Insulation fill weight: When you’re carrying a bag long distances, it’s going to be the overall bag weight that matters. Insulation fill weight tells you only the total weight of the insulation that is in the bag. It can be used as a general indicator of bag warmth — after all, more fill in a bag down make it warmer. But the temperature rating of a bag is a more reliable indicator of the bag’s warmth.

Sleeping Bag Shape Affects Weight

A bag with a sleek shape and a snug fit will be much lighter than a roomier bag, simply because less fabric is present. Bags generally come in three basic shapes:

  • Mummy: A mummy bag has a slim cut with a contoured hood that is closeable for enhanced warmth. The slim cut boosts warmth and reduces weight. The fit of a mummy bag is snug — if you roll over, the bag will roll with you.
  • Semi-rectangular: Some people refer to a semi-rectangular bag as a ‘modified mummy’ bag. The semi-rectangular designation is used to cover a variety of shapes that balance warmth and roominess.
  • Rectangular: This shape sacrifices warmth for extra roominess. The rectangular sleeping is one of the more traditional shapes.

How does the sleeping bag shape affects warmth? Sleeping bags retain heat that is produced by your body. This heat can sufficiently warm up a small space, like the one produced by sleek and snug mummy-style bags. Roomy bags will not get quite as warm.

Get the Best Sleeping Bag Fit

The dimensions of a certain shape of sleeping bag can vary widely from brand to brand. Like shoe brands, different sleeping bag brands have different fits. We suggest ‘trying on’ bags at Great Miami Outfitters.

Sleeping bags come in a variety of sizes:

Adult sleeping bags: Available in regular and long sizes. Occasionally, you might also find these in short or petite sizes. If your height is close to the upper end of a size’s ‘fits up to’ measurement, we suggest going one size up. However, if you choose the smaller of the two sizes, you may save some weight and stay a little bit warmer.

Women-specific sleeping bags: These are typically shorter and narrower at the shoulders, and are engineered to fit the ‘average woman’s’ shape over men’s or a unisex style bag.

Kids’ sleeping bags: Basically, kids’ sleeping bags are just shorter and smaller variations of the adult models. ISO and EN testing can’t be done on these bags, but many brands still provide estimated temperature ratings.

Sleeping Bag Features

Sleeping bag hood: Hoods offer additional warmth when cinched in tightly around the sleeper’s head. You may find differentiated drawcords on some bags, which feature different thicknesses. This way, users can easily determine which cord adjusts your neck fit and which adjusts your hood opening.

Draft-blocking features: To prevent warm air from escaping, some bags feature draft tubes that run the length of the bag. Yokes can be found at the top of the bag which will also prevent warm air from escaping.

Anti-snag zipper: Snagging your zipper isn’t just annoying — it causes unneeded wear and tear. To prevent this, some bags feature shields around the zipper with a guard along its full length. Other bags may come with a zipper cover.

Left or right zip: This only matters if you are a couple looking to zip two bags together. One person will need a left-hand zip bag and the other will need a right-hand zip bag. They must also be the same type of zipper. If a brand makes the same bag in men’s and women’s varieties, the men’s will generally be a left zip and the women’s will be a right zip. You can also simply buy double bags which are specifically designed for two sleepers.

Stash pocket: Often found on the chest panel of the bag, a stash pocket is useful for keeping small personal items.

Sleeping pad compatibility: On some bags, the bottom insulation is replaced with a sleeve that fits a sleeping pad. Pad loops also allow you to use straps to connect a sleeping pad to your bag.

Pillow pocket: This clever feature is a pocket in which users can stuff clothes to create a sort of pillow or insert a inflatable backpacking pillow.

Sleeping bag fabric: Backpacking bags are usually made with ripstop nylon or polyester. These shell fabrics are often treated with a durable water repellent finish that prevents water from soaking through to dampen or damage the filling. Meanwhile, lining fabrics feature a brushed texture for added softness.

Additional Sleeping Bag Accessories

Stuff sack: Many stuff sacks are waterproof bags that allow you to compress your bag down for quick storage and transportation.

Storage sack: Leaving your bag in a stuff sack for too long will damage the fill and impede its insulation ability. So, a lot of bags come with included large mesh or cotton storage sacks for long-term storage

Sleeping bag liner: A soft sleeping bag liner minimizes wear and will help to keep your bag clean. Liners also provide a bit of extra warmth, which gives your bag some extra versatility.

Let us know if this article was helpful. Need more information? Stop in our store and talk to one of our fit specialists and will be happy to answer your questions.

View Sleeping Bags in stock

View Sleeping Pads in stock


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s